Northern Craftsmanship in a Southern Landscape

Georgia Journal and Messenger, 3 May 1854

Rose Hill Cemetery in Macon, Bibb County, Georgia is rarely mentioned in the same breath as Mount Auburn or Green-Wood. Yet it belongs unmistakably to the same 19th-century garden (or rural) cemetery movement, when Americans began to rethink how the dead should be remembered and where the living should encounter them. Established in 1840 on rolling ground above the Ocmulgee River, Rose Hill reflects the ideals of the movement—winding paths, carefully framed views, and monuments meant to converse quietly with the landscape rather than dominate it. Though regional in scale and ambition, it reveals how those national ideas traveled south, taking root in Georgia soil and producing a burial ground that was at once commemorative, civic, and contemplative. It is within this context—influential and deliberate—that the presence of two marble gravestones signed by a Connecticut maker begins to tell a larger story.

Though Macon had a prominent grave carver in James Artope, many of Rose Hill's early monuments were not carved locally but produced in Northern marble centers and shipped south, not only reflecting the expanding reach of 19th-century stone manufacture and distribution, but also that Maconites had cosmopolitan taste and participated in national artistic trends. Among these are two gravestones bearing the signature of John Ritter, a marble manufacturer working in New Haven, Connecticut, in the mid-nineteenth century. The presence of his work in Macon speaks to the ease with which funerary forms, materials, and aesthetics crossed regional boundaries, linking a Southern garden cemetery to Northern workshops through trade, taste, and shared commemorative language. These signed stones offer tangible evidence that Rose Hill was not a provincial outpost, but an active participant in the broader funerary economy of its time.

Two Daughters of James Hicks Hardaway

Margarett Indiana Hardaway departed this life 23 July 1843 in Macon, Bibb County, Georgia at the age of just 21 years. And it was her death that precipitated the purchase of a lot in the Central Avenue division of Rose Hill Cemetery by her father, J. H. Hardaway. Her gravestone, featuring an elegant border, is possibly the first he commissioned from John Ritter of New Haven, Connecticut.

Sacred to the Memory of
Miss Margarett Indiana Hardaway,
who departed this life,
July 23, 1843,
Æ 21 years & 23 days.

"It is not all of life to live,
nor all of death to die."

And thou art now where sunshine is Immortal,
In the bright regions of eternal joy.

Margarett's older sister died on 8 February 1851. For Ann's memorial, commissioned roughly eight years later, the family again turned to Ritter, this time selecting a stone characterized by a striking Gothic arch.

Sacred to the Memory of
Mrs. Ann Eliza,
wife of Robert Carver,
who died Feb'y 8, 1851,
Æ 36 years, 7 months & [?]

"Blessed are the dead who died in the Lord."

In the bottom left corner of each of the gravestones pictured above is the signature of John Ritter.

J. Ritter
N. Haven, Ct

A Dynasty of Stone Carvers

Connecticut Herald, 1823

John Ritter, his father David, and other members of the family were highly prominent stone carvers of New Haven, Connecticut, and their influence spanned over a century. Beginning in the mid-18th century, early members were known for a distinct folk-art style featuring simple faces with down-curved wings. By the 19th century, the family moved toward more sophisticated marble yards and monumental works.

New Haven was a hub for high-quality marble crafts. Stones were often carved there and shipped down the Atlantic coast to ports like Savannah, Georgia, then brought inland to cities such as Macon. (It's even possible they arrived by steamboat on the Ocmulgee River, which Rose Hill Cemetery overlooks.) Ordering a signed stone from a famous New Haven carver was a statement of status and ensured the finest craftsmanship for deceased loved ones. Signed stones such as the two featured here are conclusive evidence of the coastline marble trade.

After John took over the marble factory from his father, he made it a point to advertise in newspapers up and down the Atlantic coast and employed authorized agents in cities such as Macon to make it easy for local families to order. Ads in the Georgia Journal and Messenger newspaper of Macon even noted that various patterns of Ritter monuments could be seen in Rose Hill Cemetery, using the park-like space as a gallery for his work. This marketing hook proved that the Ritter marble monuments were a recognizable status symbol.

Ultimately, the signature of John Ritter etched into the marble at Rose Hill does more than just document a 19th-century trade route. It serves as a lasting bridge between a Northern workshop and a Southern family’s grief. While the steamboats that once traversed the Ocmulgee have long since vanished, these tangible and elegant stones remain. The next time you walk through a cemetery, look closely at the base of the monuments; you might just find a name that tells a story spanning hundreds of miles and nearly two centuries.

If you enjoyed this content,
please consider supporting my blog.